False positive mammograms linked to slight cancer risk increase

Women who have abnormal mammogram results may be at increased risk for developing breast cancer even when follow-up tests fail to detect tumors, a U.S. study finds.

Typically, if there is a suspicious area on a mammogram, women get additional imaging to rule out cancer, followed by a biopsy if more information is still needed to determine if the suspect cells are malignant. When the extra tests don’t find cancer, the mammogram result is considered a “false positive.”

After a false positive mammogram, the added absolute cancer risk over a 10-year period isn’t that much bigger than it would be for women who had negative results from the start, the study found.

But compared to women with negative results, those with false positives had 39 percent greater odds of developing cancer if additional imaging found the mammogram was a false alarm, and 76 percent higher odds for after biopsies negated the original positive results.

“In the vast majority of women, this additional imaging rules out cancer,” said lead study author Louise Henderson, a researcher at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

“The higher risk of developing cancer among those with a false positive result with biopsy may be due to the fact that the radiologist sees an abnormal pattern that is not cancerous but is a radiographic marker associated with subsequent cancer,” Henderson added by email.

An example of such markers on X-rays include tiny calcifications that are common and usually benign, but sometimes also associated with the site of cancer cells.

To assess the cancer risk after false positives, Henderson and colleagues reviewed data on more than 2.2 million mammograms performed in almost 1.3 million women aged 40 to 75 between 1994 and 2009.

After the initial screening, women were tracked over 10 years to evaluate breast-cancer risk over time.

Most women in the study, slightly more than 2 million, had screening mammograms with true negative results. Over the study period, about 43,000 breast cancers were found in this group, the researchers report in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention.

Among women with false positives, 159,488 were referred for additional imaging based on suspicious screening mammograms, and 4,742 cancers were later detected.

For 22,892 women with false positives who had biopsies recommended based on initial screenings, 888 cancers were found over the course of the study.

In absolute terms, the rate of cancers among women with negative imaging was 3.91 per 1,000 people per year over the 10-year study period. Women with false-positives and additional imaging had a rate of 5.91 cancers per 1,000 per year, and women who had biopsies had a rate of 7.01 cancers per 1,000 per year.

Limitations of the analysis include the possibility that some women moved away from regions included in the data set so records on some mammogram findings might be incomplete, the authors concede.

They also did not analyze the reasons why false-positive tests or additional imaging or biopsies might be linked to increased risk of cancers being diagnosed later.

Even so, the findings are significant because with regular mammograms, many women will eventually get a false positive result, the researchers note. Over the course of 10 mammograms, the odds of women getting at least one false positive result are about 61 percent for annual screenings and 42 percent for biannual tests.

False positives are so common because clinicians must strike a balance between screenings that are sensitive enough to find even the smallest abnormalities and specific enough to capture results that most likely to actually be cancer, said Dr. Richard Bleicher, a breast surgeon at Fox Chase Cancer Center in Philadelphia.

“These two characteristics are usually a trade-off,” Bleicher, who wasn’t involved in the study, said by email.

“False positives are not necessarily a completely bad thing,” Bleicher added. “They admittedly do cause anxiety. But if it ends up being that the false positives become a predictive factor for who may be at elevated risk to develop cancer, then those false positives may be an indicator of a woman’s just like any other factor that we use to predict risk, like family history or genetic testing.”

SOURCE: bit.ly/1YI9EVu Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers and Prevention, online December 2, 2015.

Women who have abnormal mammogram results may be at increased risk for developing breast cancer even when follow-up tests fail to detect tumors, a . . .

Follow Us On Google News | Get Our Newsletter



Trending News on PVDN

  • Where do foreigners come from and where do they live in MexicoMexico City Protest on July 5 Challenges Gentrification and Airbnb’s Impact on Housing Residents of Roma and Condesa will gather at Parque México on July 5 to protest gentrification, rising rents, and Airbnb’s effect on local housing. This Saturday, July 5, Mexico City will witness its first organized citizen protest against gentrification—a peaceful but urgent gathering taking place at 3:30 p.m. at the Lindbergh Forum in Parque México,…
  • raw-sewage-playa-los-muertos-puerto-vallartaMore Raw Sewage Dumping at Playa Los Muertos Appear to Come From Local Hotel Business owners in Puerto Vallarta are demanding action after raw sewage was discovered leaking onto Playa Los Muertos, raising public health and tourism concerns. A raw sewage leak at Playa Los Muertos in Puerto Vallarta has sparked outrage among local tourist service providers and business owners, who say the contamination is driving away visitors and…
  • puerto-vallarta-rainfall-hurricane-flossie-july-2025Puerto Vallarta braces for torrential rains as Hurricane Flossie gains strength Puerto Vallarta faces a high risk of flooding as Hurricane Flossie intensifies in the Pacific. Torrential rains and overwhelmed drainage systems pose major challenges for the city. Puerto Vallarta, a city wedged between the Sierra Madre mountains and the Pacific Ocean, is no stranger to dramatic weather shifts—but this summer, the skies are testing the…
  • puerto vallarta lettersPuerto Vallarta needs a new image to create meaningful reasons for travelers to visit Business leaders at Jalisco Tourism Secretariat forums stressed the need for renewing Puerto Vallarta image and diversifying attractions to appeal to national and international markets. Local business leaders and tourism specialists agreed this week that Puerto Vallarta needs a fresh look and a broader range of attractions to compete at home and abroad. In a…
  • José Luis Velázquez RodríguezSEAPAL Official Reported Missing in Puerto Vallarta Authorities in Puerto Vallarta have launched a search for José Luis Velázquez Rodríguez, SEAPAL's head of transparency, who has been missing since June 30. Family and officials are urging the public to report any information. Local authorities and civil protection units have launched a search operation for José Luis Velázquez Rodríguez, head of the Transparency…
  • mexico city real estateGentrification in Mexico City is not the reason for the high cost of housing City housing shortage, not gentrification, drives prices skyward as planning lags behind demand and foreigner influence remains minimal. High real estate costs in Mexico City stem from a deep and persistent housing shortage—exacerbated by land constraints, tangled regulations and speculative investment—rather than by the presence of foreign residents. Despite headlines blaming “gentrification,” foreign-born residents make…
  • no-damage-jalisco-hurricane-flossieNo Damage Reported in Jalisco as Hurricane Flossie Moves Away While Mexico's Weather Service predicted heavy rains, Hurricane Flossie causes no damage along Jalisco’s coast. The Category 3 storm brings light rain and moderate waves as it moves away from the region. The coasts of Jalisco remain calm and largely unaffected following the passage of Hurricane Flossie, a powerful Category 3 storm that is now…
  • hurricane-flossie-strengthens-july-1-2025Hurricane Flossie will bring tropical storm conditions to parts of Guerrero, Michoacán, Colima, and Jalisco Hurricane Flossie intensifies off Mexico's Pacific coast with winds near 90 mph. Heavy rain, flooding, and tropical storm conditions expected in parts of Guerrero, Michoacán, Colima, and Jalisco. Hurricane Flossie continued to intensify early Tuesday morning as it moved west-northwestward off the coast of southwestern Mexico, prompting tropical storm warnings and watches across multiple states.…
  • cancun-sargassum-environmental-fund-responseWhich Quintana Roo Beaches Clean From Sargassum and Those Covered Today July 4 2025 Daily sargassum tracking for July 4, 2025: see which Quintana Roo beaches are clear of sargassum and which have landings, with ongoing cleanup efforts keeping the coast visitor-ready. Welcome to the daily sargassum tracker for the Mexican Caribbean coast. Each morning, we tally which beaches in Quintana Roo remain free of sargassum and which have…
  • tropical-wave-7-floods-bacalar-chetumal-emergency-responseTropical Wave Floods Bacalar and Chetumal as Navy and Army Activate Emergency Plans Torrential rains from Tropical Wave 7 flood Bacalar and Chetumal, prompting emergency response from the Navy and Army. Several towns remain isolated in southern Quintana Roo. Torrential rains caused by Tropical Wave Number 7 have flooded multiple communities in southern Quintana Roo, prompting a joint emergency response from Mexico’s Navy and Army. Authorities activated their…
Scroll to Top